Why is All Life Carbon Based, Not Silicon? Three Startling Reasons!

this video is brought to you by one gram stay tuned for a special offer for arvinash viewers from the tallest Sequoia to the smartest human to the most poisonous mushroom to the tiniest bacterium there is one thing that unites all living things on earth and that is the fact that all life is based on carbon chemistry this element is so important in fact that it has its own branch of chemistry organic chemistry but carbon is not the most abundant element on Earth that would be oxygen and it is not the most stable like helium on

the surface it doesn't appear particularly special yet if we look at our body composition we find that carbon is everywhere in our cells twenty percent of our body is made up of carbon but it comprises less than one percent of the mass of the Earth's atmosphere oceans and crust why did life go to the trouble of concentrating carbon 20-fold in our bodies when other more abundant elements like oxygen and silicon were available or even nitrogen which makes up 78 percent of our atmosphere the big question is why we're going to examine that and we're going

to trace the logic that nature used in choosing this all-important element carbon that's coming up right now [Music] there are 94 naturally occurring elements on the periodic table why is everything based on carbon and not something else when the choices are so many the answer boils down to three things complexity abundance and stability what do I mean by this let's start with complexity carbon is able to form the complex molecular structures needed for the complex chemistry that life requires why is carbon able to do this to understand this we have to look at the foundation

of chemistry which is physics particularly quantum mechanics quantum mechanics tells us that some electron orbital configurations are more energetically favorable than others making them more stable and the most stable configuration of electrons are those of the noble gases on the far right side of the periodic table these are special elements that have a complete outer shell of electrons this is the lowest energy configuration that an atom can have this makes them chemically stable because they do not typically need to share gain or lose electrons to form bonds with other atoms to become more stable this

is also why they're chemically inert since they do not generally interact with other atoms to form molecules why are only the noble gases this way and not other elements because they happen to have the right number of protons to have the right number of electrons to fill their shell fully the driving force behind chemistry is really a hunt to get to the most energetically efficient state in a system the state of lowest energy and for the most part this lowest energy State occurs when an atom is able to fill its outermost shell fully like the

noble elements and some atoms can do this by sharing their electrons with other atoms to form what's called covalent chemical bonds the periodic table of elements is arranged in such a way that we can easily tell by column the maximum number of bonds that an element can form with other elements starting from the left column of the table the first group of atoms can form a maximum of one Bond the second column of elements can form two bonds third column three Bots this joint continues up to the fourth column which can form four bonds after

this the maximum number of bonds decreases so the fifth column of elements can only form three maximum bonds then two bonds one Bond and finally zero bonds for the rightmost column which are the noble Elements which are already the most stable what you'll notice is that carbon is in the group of elements which can form the maximum number of bonds it has a total of six electrons four of which are on its outer shell in order to fill its outermost shell it needs four more electrons to make eight like the noble gas Neon so it

can share up to four additional electrons from other atoms to form covalent bonds making it more stable this makes carbon very versatile imagine if Lego bricks could be connected on four sides instead of two it would make building things easier each carbon atom can form a strong stable bond with up to four other atoms including other carbon atoms this feature of carbon gives it the ability to form complex molecules which is necessary for the complex chemical functions that life requires carbon-based molecules can form long non-repetitive chains of polymers they can form closed rings and they

can form single double or triple bonds with other elements there are millions of possible configurations taken together this makes carbon uniquely able to take part in a vast multitude of chemical processes it can easily form long stable polymer chains that can for example carry a lot of information this is the case for DNA DNA after all carries all the information that makes up living things including us and the four nucleotides that make up the building blocks of DNA are complex carbon is the backbone partly because it can handle this complexity the other elements are not

as interesting take for example oxygen which is the most abundant element on Earth it can form only two bonds this means that once it bonds with two other atoms it's done it can't really form interesting scaffolds of complex molecules like carbon can Boron could be interesting because it can form three bonds so its molecular structures could also be fairly complex the problem is that it's extremely rare so it's just not very available for life to have chosen it as its backbone this brings us to the second factor that made carbon attractive for life to latch

onto abundance not only is carbon versatile it's also abundant if we look at the top five most abundant elements in our solar system what we will see is the following in order of abundance hydrogen helium oxygen carbon and nitrogen now if we look at the top five elements in our body what we will see is the following in order of abundance oxygen carbon hydrogen nitrogen and calcium so what we see is that four out of the top five elements of the solar system are also among the top five elements making up the human body this

gives us another clue about why life is based on carbon there's plenty of it in the universe very abundant it's easier to build something that you have a lot of you can't build a castle if you don't have enough Lego bricks at this point you might say if abundance is so important then what about silicon which is abundant and can also form four bonds or nitrogen which can form only three bonds but makes up 78 percent of our atmosphere this brings us to the third factor in determining the most suitable element that nature chose for

Life stability what I mean by this is Bond stability let's look at that as I said earlier the structure of the periodic table is such that as a rule of thumb all elements in each column have the same general properties carbon turns out to be the lightest element in the group of 14 or 4 depending on how you count therefore we would expect that the sister elements like Silicon and germanium would have similar chemical properties silicon is the next lightest element in the column its position on the periodic table tells us that like carbon it

also has four valence electrons this means it can also make four covalent bonds for every molecule made out of carbon there can be an analogous molecule with silicon in its place silicon also happens to be quite abundant on Earth in fact there's more silicon on Earth than carbon it's just locked up in rocks within the Earth's crust chemically silicon has four unpaired electrons in its outer orbital just like carbon the main difference is that silicon has its unpaired electrons farther away from its nucleus on its third shell whereas carbon's electrons are on its second shell

closer to the nucleus this makes silicon's electrons more weakly bound to its nucleus the consequence of this is that when silicon bonds with other atoms including itself the bonds formed are weaker and thus less stable to give you some numbers the Silicon silicon bond strength is 196 in contrast carbon-carbon bonds are stronger at 334. this bond strength factor is also a reason nitrogen is not well suited to be the backbone of organic chemistry as its bond strength is roughly half of carbon you can't make a skyscraper with a foundation built from cardboard the structural support

has to be strong to hold the walls windows and doors organic molecules have the same need the backbone has to be strong enough to withstand the conditions under which other parts of the molecule break their bonds and react chemically with other molecules so the carbon-carbon scaffold needs to remain intact while the functional components break apart a molecular scaffold made from nitrogen or silicon would more easily break apart so if we go back now to the periodic table and look at the three rows of elements if you remove all the chemically inert elements and then remove

elements that can't form more than two bonds then we remove all the elements that are exceedingly low in abundance we end up with carbon nitrogen and silicon then if we remove those that cannot form strong single bonds to themselves to create a strong molecular backbone this leaves pretty much only carbon as the best choice it is uniquely suited for life because of the best combination of abundance ability to form complex structures and stable bonds with other carbon atoms now having said all that there's nothing that would preclude silicon-based life forms from existing on an extraterrestrial

Planet if the conditions were right for it by this logic we can also Imagine life based on germanium 10 or even super dense creatures made of lead but we have to keep in mind mind that as elements get heavier they tend to be more rare so each of these is less plausible than the last for example germanium is at least five orders of magnitude less abundant than carbon and tint is even rarer it so happens that the pressures and temperatures on earth work well for life forms that use liquid water as the solvent and carbon-based

molecules that can form a stable backbone on which biological chemistry can take place if it gets too cold water turns to ice and will have problems with chemical transport if it gets too hot we'll get issues with carbon polymer chains breaking too easily we may never know for sure but it's perfectly possible that carbon trumps everything else except an extreme environment but we can't rule anything out and we need to be open-minded about conditions in which life could hypothetically occur for example there are lakes of ethane and methane on Titan under the conditions of Titan

these are liquids and like water on Earth they could be used as a solvent by a different type of life form so at different temperatures and pressures it is conceivable that a different element may be more conducive to life one of my patreon supporters pointed out that we carbon life forms May right now be in the process of creating silicon artificial life forms and this process is accelerating this form of life could very likely exist in the near future right here on Earth but there's no evidence for life outside of Earth it could be quite

rare in the universe so you can have all the various elements available in abundance but the interactions are chemistry of these various elements is the critical process needed for life to happen that process is organic chemistry and for further study I'd highly recommend a great course I recently watched on Mondrian sponsor of today's video called foundations of organic chemistry and just as the title implies it'll help you grasp the details and foundations of the material I covered in this video it's a 36 lecture course that takes you on a Learning Journey from the basics of

atoms to the formation of the most important organic chemicals to the mechanism behind organic chemical reactions the first course is even called y carbon it's taught by Professor Ron Davis of Georgetown University whose Lucid explanations makes this subject relevant and easily graspable you'll find many other wonderful courses like this and one dream taught by some of the best Educators in the world like Professor Davis that's why I've been a member of wondering for a long time and you'll even find my testimonial at the bottom of their home page they're offering a free trial right now

so it's really easy to sign up you can cancel at any time so you've got nothing to lose and a lot to gain if you click the link in the description you'll get a free trial so be sure to take advantage of their free offer that that link is onedrim.com Arvin that's wondriam.com and you'll be supporting this channel when you sign up so I really want to thank you for that and if you like this video and want to be informed for future videos like this be sure to subscribe and if you have a question

please post it in the comment section I'll do my very best to try to answer it I'll see you in the next video my friend [Music] foreign [Music]