The EU’s Migration Crisis Explained

this video was brought to you by skillshare if you even glance at the headlines it can feel like Europe is souring on immigration in just the last week Switzerland's Federal elections were won by the migrant skeptic Swiss People's Party inferior ministers from across the EU released a statement demanding tighter immigration rules and even the usually liberal Olaf Schultz gave an interview with Des spel arguing for a more aggressive Deport ation system while this renewed focus on immigration is in part a reaction to the recent events namely a europe-wide rise in anti-semitic offenses and Hamas based

Terror attacks in France and Belgium immigration has been rising steadily up the eu's agenda for some time now in France macron said last month that he wanted to significantly reduce immigration in Italy Maloney has called for a naval blockade of the Italian Coast and warned that the EU could be overwhelmed by immigration and in the Netherlands Mark Rutter's government was brought down by internal disagreements over immigration so in this video we're going to take a look at why this migration is such a Hot Topic in the EU at the moment why the eu's current system

doesn't work and whether the EU can fix [Music] it before we start if you haven't already please consider subscri subcribing and ringing the bell to stay in the loop and be notified when we release new videos so let's get straight into it why has immigration been rising up the eu's agenda recently well the fundamental reason is an increase in migrant numbers well the EU has seen a significant increase in what sometimes known as regular migration largely as a result of 4 million or so ukrainians that have fled Putin's Invasion it's also seen a significant increase

in what's known as irregular migration I.E Asylum Seekers and undocumented migrants in 2022 the EU received over 900,000 Asylum requests a rise of more than 50% when compared to 2021 and the highest figure since 2016 and provisional data from this year suggests that Asylum requests will up another 28% in the first half of 2023 which would imply an annual figure of about 1.2 million similarly the eu's Border agency frontex detected over 300,000 unauthorized arrivals in 2022 the highest number since 2016 now these might be europe-wide figures but certain countries have been acutely affected Italy for

example has received over 130,000 irregular migrants so far this year already overtaking the total number from last year anyhow these Rising numbers have exposed and highlighted the various flaws with the eu's current migration system now to understand the problems with the current system we need to go back to the mid90s when the EU first introduced the shenen area for those of you who don't know the shenen area allows Visa free travel I.E freedom of movement between member countries and today comprises of the vast majority of EU countries and even a couple of non countries covering

a total area of over 4 million square kilm and 423 million people now while Shen's introduction was celebrated as a great European success it's also created an anxiety in some member states that other states would now have little incentive to properly police their borders because without intra euu borders they could just push unwanted migrants onto other shenen area countries now to wagees anxiety the EU introduced the Dublin Accords which required irregular immigration to be processed in the country of Aral that means if say Italy lets a whole load of migrants pass into France without processing

them France can send them back to Italy unfortunately this system created the opposite problem it put too much strain on the countries at the eu's external borders often called Frontier countries which receive the majority of The eu's Irregular migrants as such when migrant numbers have risen recently Frontier countries have reacted by implementing illiberal immigration policies which has provoked criticism from other EU countries on human rights grounds late last year for example France criticized Italy for refusing to take in a migrant rescue ship which was then docked in southern France and Italy is currently feuding with

Germany over its funding of Migrant rescue Charities oper operating in the Mediterranean which Italy thinks encourages irregular migration now the EU has tried to remedy this issue with a voluntary solidarity mechanism which obliges signed up non-frontier countries to take in a few thousand migrants from the frontier countries but it's not a permanent solution because well it's voluntary which is why countries like Poland and Hungary haven't signed up to it and both Germany and France temporarily pulled out of it after their spat with Italy that's not all though there are at least two other problems with

the eu's current migration system firstly while they do have a common internal migration policy in shenen the EU has no common external migration policy the current system is a confused mess of national and EU legislation with a wide range of immigration policies now some countries are more accepting of regular migrants in 2021 for example Poland issued nearly 800,000 work visas to non-eu Citizens more than the rest of the EU combined similarly some countries are more accepting of irregular migrants in 2016 for example Italy granted Asylum to nearly 95% of Syrian refugees while Croatia granted Asylum

to just 12% the second problem with the system is that the policies are just often poorly enforced many Frontier countries lack the resources to properly police their borders or Implement their policies and this is especially true in the western Balkans which was one of the most popular routes for irregular migration into the EU in 2022 the EU has tried to remedy this by investing in frontex its border security Force but even if the EU was able to perfectly police its borders it doesn't have the administrative capacity to process the number of irregular migrants currently around

driving into the EU according to the latest data available the EU currently has an asylum application backlog of about 900,000 including backlogs of over a 100,000 in Italy Spain France and Germany the EU also struggles to deal with the 60% or so of Asylum Seekers who have their applications rejected with few of them one in five successfully deported anyway these two problems the intra-european variation in attitudes towards external m migration and the fact that many European countries struggle to enforce their external migration policies have seriously strained shenan distrustful of their neighbors migration policies many shenan

members have reintroduced border controls at the time of writing 10 countries have formally reintroduced border controls using Shen's emergency mechanism with many citing the recent spike in irregular migration and a hanville more have been quietly increasing ing border policing without notifying the European commission you get the idea then the EU currently lacks a cohesive external migration policy and this in turn is undermining its internal migration policy that's why for the past few years the EU has been trying to come up with a new external migration policy and at the moment this seems to have two

elements the first is the new EU pact on migration and Asylum first proposed by the European Commission in September 2020 and finally agreed by member states earlier this month now there's a lot in the deal and if you want to know more we'd recommend that you go and watch this video which is linked in the description but perhaps the most interesting element is the mandatory solidarity pact which aims to relocate 30,000 Asylum Seekers from Frontier countries to non-frontier countries specifically if non-frontier countries don't accept these migrants then they'll be fined roughly 20,000 per migrant refused

which has provoked some upset in countries like Poland and Hungary Poland and Hungary was not satisfied with the proposal but they pushed us through I mean pushed through the proposal so Hungary and Poland was totally left out of that so after this there is no any chance to have any kind of compromise and agreement on migration because legally we are uh how to say it we are raped so if you are raped legally forced to accept something what you don't like how would you like to have a compromise and agreement it's impossible now while getting

this deal done is a diplomatic success the deal still needs to be negotiated with the European Parliament and then ratified which means that it's unlikely to come into Force for another few years it's not just that deal though the second element of the eu's new external migration policy is a series of deals with socalled Transit States I.E those countries which migrants Transit through before reaching the EU which involves the EU giving these countries money to help them police their borders more effectively the first of these deals came into force in 2016 when the EU agreed

to give turkey billions of Euros to stem the tide of migrants coming into the EU and its success encouraged the EU to sign similar deals with Libya in 2018 Morocco in 2022 and Tunisia in July of this year but while these deals have been relatively successful they have at least three problems firstly reducing migrant flows from one Transit country usually only increases migrant flows from another this is what happened in 2016 because while the deal reduced flows from Turkey migrants just started traveling via Libya instead and when the EU reached a deal with Libya then

they started coming via Tunisia secondly it's just unsustainable again turkey is a good example here originally turkey was happy to take in the migrants itself aided by EU funding but now turkey has taken in an astonishing 4 million migrants and public sympathy within the country is apparently waning migration was a big Topic in this year's elections in turkey and erdogan is even trying to send back Syrian migrants to Turkish occupied parts of Syria and the third issue is that it's just not clear that these deals are consistent with the eu's values and human rights in

Libya for example the Libyan Coast Guard which is really more of a regional militia than a National Police Service has been accused of various human rights abuses including detaining migrants in prisons and using them for slave labor ultimately given the competing electoral demographic and economic demands it shouldn't come as a surprise that there's no easy solution for the EU when it comes to immigration but the continuing problems over the solidarity packs demonstrate quite how politically difficult this problem is really becoming a few weeks ago we told you that we were making a physical newspaper but

it turns out that designing a newspaper isn't all that easy so we headed to skillshare to take their course on the topic and unlike when I tried to learn in design for another never relased project a few years ago this time I was guided through the process quickly and efficiently and this time the project will actually see the light of day thanks to skillshare's incredibly easy to follow guides in fact here's an exclusive little preview of what we've been working on it's not just that either you likely already know that skillshare have classes for things

like photography editing and illustration but skillshare also have hundreds of career focused classes too that courses on everything from how to start a business to maximizing your workflow or how to grow in e-commerce another course that I'm taking to help with the new newspaper and if you use our Link in the description you'll get access to all of that for free that's right the first 500 people to use our link will get access to one of skillshare's best offers a 30-day free trial and 40% of your first year of skillshare membership as I say that's

the best skillshare offer that we've ever had so make sure that you click our Link in the description thanks for your support and thanks to skillshare for sponsoring this video